Good location, but room and bathroom quality fell short
Hotel Catalina's biggest strength is location — it's an easy walk into Cadaqués and close to the Costa Brava trails, which made it a great base for exploring on foot. Parking is dedicated per room, which was genuinely handy and one less thing to worry about. The hotel is also dog-friendly.
Unfortunately the room itself let things down. It had a persistent smell, and the bathroom needs attention: grime buildup between the shower tiles, no soap dish, and all the water faucets were loose and overdue for replacement. On the plus side, the bed was firm and comfortable, and the kitchen had all the basics for self-catering.
Front desk staff were a mixed bag — some were friendly and helpful, others seemed like they'd rather be anywhere else.
Overall, I don't think the price-to-value ratio is quite there given the room/bathroom issues, though I understand this is a busy, high-demand area. Still a reasonable pick for a longer stay if the location matters most to you.