I stayed at Atlantis Hotel, Melbourne for two nights and while it had everything I needed for a comfortable stay, it wasn't as nice as the photos on the site made it look.
My room looked tired and could have done with an update. I'd say this was most noticeable with the furniture - the room had a couch which was a nice thought, but there was no way I was going to sit on that thing!
I appreciated that the room had an iron / ironing board as that seems to be less common in hotels now. It was very useful to make my clothes look more presentable after a day of travel.
The staff at the desk were very nice, and each time I emailed through ahead of my stay, they replied very soon after with a pleasant tone.
The location of this hotel was good - if you're heading to Marvel Stadium for a concert, this could be a good choice. But if you're planning on doing a lot of walking and shopping in the main CBD, perhaps look at something closer to that area to save your feet.
While the tram lines run down Spencer Street, this is a bit confusing to get your head around as a tourist (what's free and what's not), but if you can figure that out, perhaps this location will work just fine for you.
There's some restaurants around the area, and it's nice and close to both the Southern Cross train station, and the Sky Bus station, which can make life a bit easier when you're on and off public transport.