Brittany at the front desk was on top of her game, attending to every detail with professional excellence. The place was immaculate and has earned every bit of its high rating. Sometimes food in hotel lobby restaurants can be questionable, but not here, the food was amazing, in particular, the french onion and bacon omelet with potato bites. The rooftop bar was phenomenal even in the heat, great views! Parking is across the street but easy to get to from the street or the back entrance.
The hotel is located within walking distance to a number of restaurants. Both York and the hotel not only look charming and nostalgic but also feel that way while spending time there.
The only glitch and far from a deal killer is that due to this being an old hotel in the city, the main/best entrance is in the rear on E Mason Avenue. However, maps takes you to the rntrance on E Market Street which has an inset in the curb...but only for buses and emergencies. That doesn't sound like a problem, however, you can't just "go around the block". In order to approach the hotel from the one way E Mason Ave, you have to go around several blocks to get there. As it is unlikely that York will change it's one way street system, perhaps using the rear entrance in maps software which could avoid some extra driving.